Though
Andy Bellin claims to be a semipro poker player this book is more a
journalistic approach to the game of poker than an insider report as the
cover pretends. The target audience for this book is definitely home
games poker players who want to find out more about their favorite game
and not serious poker players. Each chapter deals with a specific aspect
of the game, but most of the time the treatment is superficial. The discussion
about playing hands, bluffing and odds is very simplistic. For example, he
tells you that if you hold pocket queens in hold’em with a the flop of T♣-J♠-Q♣,
and the “turn is another club or straight card, your three queens become
almost unplayable.” This might be true in pot limit, but in limit poker
this is total nonsense. You always have the correct pot odds to draw for
a full house or quads. The included chart about odds and probability, taken
from Ken Warren’s book “Winner’s Guide to Texas Hold’em Poker”, leaves a bad impression for two reasons. First, Warren’s book is a
dubious source at best (fortunately the numbers are correct in this
case) and second, it’s not too difficult to do the calculations yourself.
Frankly, a seven year old schoolboy with a pocket calculator
could figure it out.
The chapter on “Big-Time Pros” is odd. Bellin describes how he and
another journalist tried to get an interview from Huck Seed and Johnny
Chan. Then there are some secondhand stories about Stuey Unger and
that’s about it. There is too little and what there is of it is not very
satisfying or enlightening. I like Jesse May’s novel “Shut up and Deal” in this
respect much better. Though it is fictional, it gives you an intense and
somehow depressing description of the lifestyle of these so-called high
limit poker players. The best chapter of Bellin’s book is
the one on “Small-Time Pros”. The story of professional middle limit
Hold 'Em player Dicky Horvath is colorful, full of suspense, and very
moving. On the other hand, this chapter can be misleading.
Because Bellin only presents this isolated case without any comments,
the reader might come to the erroneous conclusion that typical pros are
mostly drug addicts and cheaters. I know a lot of professional middle
limit players and as far as I know none of them is a drug addict or a
cheater.
Bellin's
book is aimed at the mass market. Strictly speaking, it is for people
who play once in a while in a poker game and want to learn more about
the game. The book serves its purpose in this respect. Many of the
stories and anecdotes Bellin includes are entertaining, and the book is
without a doubt well written, but for the serious poker player there is
nothing new in it.
(Tristan Steiger)
Buy the book!